Which is the best storyteller?

[Orange1861]

Which is your favorite storyteller for the most realistic and fun games? I like Randy with this modhttps://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=872473981 that makes funny events happen to raids sometimes and increases randomness. However, many people say that Randy is weak and doesn't provide a challenge ever in the late game, much earlier than Cassandra. So what is your opinion on this?

[Calahan]

There was a very recent Randy vs Cassandra discussion that you might want to check out.
https://ludeon.com/forums/index.php?topic=32262.0

If this thread develops predominantly down the same Randy vs Cassandra path, then I'll likely merge this thread with the one above. Since we don't need two threads for the same topic, and certainly not in such quick succession.

[Edixo]

I feel like different storytellers go best with different difficulties.

Cass goes well with anything up to rough. Randy goes well with rough. Phoebe is good for extreme.

[Nainara]

I like Cassandra, but I'd prefer a version that resets the timer-based threat strength when you abandon your colony location. As it stands, it's never a viable strategy to evacuate, even in the event of an existential threat.