Project Armory Testboard

Started by Evul, April 10, 2014, 10:02:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic
Print
Go Down Pages 1 ... 3 4 5
User actions

Bog

#60
August 14, 2014, 07:17:36 PM Last Edit: August 14, 2014, 07:25:18 PM by Bog
Here's some data:

The numbers are "Power Ratings", measured with the Rimworld Weapons Balancer. I've included all the vanilla weapons so we can see where things are in comparison to each other.


List wih eras in order of appearance:
Code Select

American Civil War weapons:

LeMat Carbine: 79.91
LeMat Revolver: 57.07


Flintlock Weapons:

Flintlock Fowler Ball: 75.40
Flintlock Folwer Shot: 51.31
Kentucky Long Rifle: 74.35


Medieval Weapons:

Crossbow: 123.11
Yew Longbow: 125.07


Modern Weapons:

Pistol: 124 (Vanilla Weapon)
Shotgun: 124 (Vanilla Weapon)
Uzi: 145 (Vanilla Weapon)
M-16: 229 (Vanilla Weapon)
M24: 240 (Vanilla Weapon)
LMG-15: 264 (Vanilla Weapon)
AA-12: 150.26
Pancor Jackhammer: 148.8
Mateba Autorevolver: 132.20
Mateba Grifone: 170.84
McMillan_Tac-50: 483.84
Saiga-12 152.30
S&W Model 29: 130.33
USAS-12: 138.58
Walther PPK: 86.74
Walther PPK (S): 78.85
Accuracy Int. AWM: 553.41
AK-47: 251.58
AKs-74U: 251.58
ASval: 220.13
BarrettM107: 508.42
BarrettM82: 495.38
CM901: 245.18
Colt Police Positive: 95.90
Desert Eagle Mk.1: 157.73
DragunovSVD: 512
FAMAS G2: 261.93
FN FAL: 248.92
FN P90: 190.08
Franchi SPAS-12: 84.02
Glock 18: 236.60
H&K G11: 210.16
H&K G36C: 247.65
H&K UMP.45: 219.37
KRISS Vector: 326.7
L58A1: 216.63
Lupara: 75.09
M-14: 324.27
M-14 EBR: 250.68
M1911: 54.30
M249: 393.47
M25: 412.29
M2 Browning: 598.66
M30 Luftwaffe Drilling: 210.96
M4A1: 206.67
M60: 381.93
Mac 10: 213.6
Mossberg 500: 110.98
MP5A2: 286.94
PK: 718.48
RPD: 718.48
SA58 Tactical 206.37
SCAR-L Mk.16 Standard: 177.14
SG552Commando: 212.21
Steyr AUGA1 204.58
VSS Vintorez: 427.76
vz58P: 178.43
vz58V: 178.43
Walther WA2000: 451.44
Winchester Model 70: 334.12


Prewar Weapons:

Apache: 65.84
British Bulldog: 61.14
Gabbett-Fairfax Mars: 134.36
Madsen-Rasmussen M1896: 266.8
Sjögren Rifle: 139.65
Sjögren Shotgun: 130.8
Steyr-Mannlicher M1894: 86.45
Steyr-Mannlicher M1901: 96.06
Webley-Fosbery: 90.79
Winchester M1907: 160.94


Prohibition Weapons:

Browning Auto 5: 120.65
Colt Monitor: 248.05
Lebman M1907: 220.60
Lebman M1911: 135.38
Sawed-off Browning A5: 102.24


Renaissance Weapons:

Dragon: 52.89


Sci-fi Weapons:

Charge Lance: 190 (Vanilla Weapon)
R4: 312 (Vanilla Weapon)
Minigun: 369 (Vanilla Weapon) (Strongest weapon avalible to the play in the vanilla version)
Heavy Charge Blaster: 380 (Vanilla Weapon)
N64 Moonraker Laser: 148.11
Moonraker Laser: 155.52
Moonraker Pistol: 98.74
D3 Plasma Gun: 255.07
T2 Plasma Rifle: 238.53
TRW Plasma Sniper: 282.06
M4A1 Pulse Rifle: 758.71
Vera: 218.4
MA5DICWS: 350.15
M8 Avenger: 252.0
M-81 Pulse Rifle: 379.82
BRX-A1: 200
BRX-A2: 200
CS19: 193.53
I. Pulase Ventor: 88.45
I. Ventor: 126.35
Morita Mk.1 AR: 350.3
Morita Mk.1 Carbine: 232.99
E-11 Blaster Rifle: 147.84
Sarcos K-11: 140.14
Bolter: 536.28
Bolt Pistol: 199.38
Lasgun: 106.67
Laspistol: 69.65


Tribal Weapons:

Thrown Stones: 25 (Vanilla Weapon)
Pila: 74 (Vanilla Weapon) (Weakest weapon avalible to the player in the vanilla version)
Short Bow: 78 (Vanilla Weapon)
Great Bow: 109 (Vanilla Weapon)
Atlatl: 95.00
Woomera: 80.08


World War 1 Weapons:

Lee-Enfield: 172 (Vanilla Weapon)
Carcano M91: 218.88
Chauchat: 284.40
Huot: 298.93
BAR M1918: 268.8
MP-18: 219.70
Ross Rifle: 221.42
Roth-Steyr M1907: 96.06
Star M1914: 96.06
Steyr M1912: 109.77
Steyr M1912 MP: 197.17
Steyr-Mannlicher M1895: 221.76
Webley Revolver: 93.42
Lebel M1888: 96.84


World War 2 Weapons:

M2 Browning: 598.66
Boys AT Rifle: 413.95
British Apache: 82.01
Thompson M1928A1: 390.23
Bren: 515.58
Luger P08: 109.78
M2 Browning (again): 355.22
Mauser C96: 120.9
MP-40: 224.26
Nambu: 96.05
Thompson M1920: 452.31


Vanilla Weapons:

Thrown Stones: 25
Pila: 74
Short Bow: 78
Great Bow: 109
Pistol: 124
Shotgun: 124
Uzi: 145
Lee-Enfield: 172
Charge Lance: 190
M-16: 229
M24: 240
LMG-15: 264
R4: 312
Minigun: 369 (Vanilla Weapon. Also, see note.)
Heavy Charge Blaster: 380 (Vanilla weapon. Also, see note.)

(The following have a "Forced Miss Radius" which has been taken into account but may not be calculated correctly)
Minigun: 369
Heavy Charge Blaster: 380
Without forced radius they'd be:
Minigun:      1123
Heavy Charge Blaster:   1186


List without eras in order of power rating:
Code Select
Thrown Stones: 25 (Vanilla Weapon)
Flintlock Folwer Shot: 51.31
Dragon: 52.89
M1911: 54.30
LeMat Revolver: 57.07
British Bulldog: 61.14
Apache: 65.84
Laspistol: 69.65
Pila: 74 (Vanilla Weapon) (Weakest weapon avalible to the player in the vanilla version)
Kentucky Long Rifle: 74.35
Lupara: 75.09
Flintlock Fowler Ball: 75.40
Short Bow: 78 (Vanilla Weapon)
Walther PPK (S): 78.85
LeMat Carbine: 79.91
Woomera: 80.08
British Apache: 82.01
Franchi SPAS-12: 84.02
Steyr-Mannlicher M1894: 86.45
Walther PPK: 86.74
I. Pulase Ventor: 88.45
Webley-Fosbery: 90.79
Webley Revolver: 93.42
Atlatl: 95.00
Colt Police Positive: 95.90
Nambu: 96.05
Steyr-Mannlicher M1901: 96.06
Roth-Steyr M1907: 96.06
Star M1914: 96.06
Lebel M1888: 96.84
Moonraker Pistol: 98.74
Sawed-off Browning A5: 102.24
Lasgun: 106.67
Great Bow: 109 (Vanilla Weapon)
Steyr M1912: 109.77
Luger P08: 109.78
Mossberg 500: 110.98
Browning Auto 5: 120.65
Mauser C96: 120.9
Crossbow: 123.11
Pistol: 124 (Vanilla Weapon)
Shotgun: 124 (Vanilla Weapon)
Yew Longbow: 125.07
I. Ventor: 126.35
S&W Model 29: 130.33
Sjögren Shotgun: 130.8
Mateba Autorevolver: 132.20
Lebman M1911: 135.38
USAS-12: 138.58
Sjögren Rifle: 139.65
Sarcos K-11: 140.14
Uzi: 145 (Vanilla Weapon)
E-11 Blaster Rifle: 147.84
N64 Moonraker Laser: 148.11
Pancor Jackhammer: 148.8
AA-12: 150.26
Saiga-12 152.30
Moonraker Laser: 155.52
Desert Eagle Mk.1: 157.73
Winchester M1907: 160.94
Mateba Grifone: 170.84
Lee-Enfield: 172 (Vanilla Weapon)
SCAR-L Mk.16 Standard: 177.14
vz58P: 178.43
vz58V: 178.43
Charge Lance: 190 (Vanilla Weapon)
FN P90: 190.08
CS19: 193.53
Steyr M1912 MP: 197.17
Bolt Pistol: 199.38
BRX-A1: 200
BRX-A2: 200
Steyr AUGA1 204.58
SA58 Tactical 206.37
M4A1: 206.67
H&K G11: 210.16
M30 Luftwaffe Drilling: 210.96
SG552Commando: 212.21
Mac 10: 213.6
L58A1: 216.63
Vera: 218.4
Carcano M91: 218.88
H&K UMP.45: 219.37
MP-18: 219.70
ASval: 220.13
Lebman M1907: 220.60
Ross Rifle: 221.42
Steyr-Mannlicher M1895: 221.76
MP-40: 224.26
M-16: 229 (Vanilla Weapon)
Morita Mk.1 Carbine: 232.99
Glock 18: 236.60
T2 Plasma Rifle: 238.53
M24: 240 (Vanilla Weapon)
CM901: 245.18
H&K G36C: 247.65
Colt Monitor: 248.05
FN FAL: 248.92
M-14 EBR: 250.68
AK-47: 251.58
AKs-74U: 251.58
M8 Avenger: 252.0
D3 Plasma Gun: 255.07
FAMAS G2: 261.93
LMG-15: 264 (Vanilla Weapon)
Madsen-Rasmussen M1896: 266.8
BAR M1918: 268.8
TRW Plasma Sniper: 282.06
Chauchat: 284.40
MP5A2: 286.94
Huot: 298.93
R4: 312 (Vanilla Weapon)
M-14: 324.27
KRISS Vector: 326.7
Winchester Model 70: 334.12
MA5DICWS: 350.15
Morita Mk.1 AR: 350.3
M2 Browning (again): 355.22
Minigun: 369 (Vanilla Weapon) (Strongest weapon avalible to the play in the vanilla version)
M-81 Pulse Rifle: 379.82
Heavy Charge Blaster: 380 (Vanilla Weapon)
M60: 381.93
Thompson M1928A1: 390.23
M249: 393.47
M25: 412.29
Boys AT Rifle: 413.95
VSS Vintorez: 427.76
Walther WA2000: 451.44
Thompson M1920: 452.31
McMillan_Tac-50: 483.84
BarrettM82: 495.38
BarrettM107: 508.42
DragunovSVD: 512
Bren: 515.58
Bolter: 536.28
Accuracy Int. AWM: 553.41
M2 Browning: (Again) 598.66
M2 Browning: (Again) 598.66
PK: 718.48
RPD: 718.48
M4A1 Pulse Rifle: 758.71

Some things I've noticed:

Most of our shotguns are underpowered. They almost all have 4 less damage then the vanilla shotgun and also shoot slower.

Most of our sniper rifles are overpowered. They tend to be almost twice as good as the vanilla sniper rifle.

The PK, RPD and M4A1 Pulse Rifle are VERY overpowered.


Overall I think we should come up with a list of where we'd like our power rankings to be, in accordance to weapon type, era, etc. Then we can come up with target power rankings for each weapon and then balance in accordance to it.


Also, the RPD and PK should have different stats, currently they are identical even though they are very different guns.

Likewise the AK-47 and AK-74 are currently identical, but in reality they're very different guns, they just look similar. In this case they even use different bullets.



Weapons not rated on this list:

M79 (Modern Launcher)
RPG7 (Modern Launcher)
Hand Mortar (Renaissance Launcher)
Thermal Detonators (Sci-fi Grenade)
Razor Wind (Sci-fi spinning boomerang)
Falarica (Tribal incendiary)
Bolas (Tribal Spinner)
Chakram (Tribal Spinner)
Kpinga (Tribal Spinner)
Boomerang (Tribal spinning boomerang)
Divergence of Civilization Lead Developer (in this case that's the fancy way of saying "Only Developer")

Project Armoury Developer (New huge 2.13 Release now live!)

Iwillbenicetou

#61
August 21, 2014, 05:47:34 PM
Could I be a tester?
Mod Help! The basics on how to download mods!

Evul

#62
August 22, 2014, 08:35:13 AM
Yes you can :) I'll add you to the pm list. :)

Evul

#63
November 16, 2014, 03:51:37 PM Last Edit: November 16, 2014, 04:12:32 PM by Evul
New DevBuild is released.
New devbuild is released download it throe the link provided. This is not a official release and may features might be lacking. This version can also be weary unstable.

Report bugs or things that need to be balanced i this thread!

Changelog:
Code Select
===========================================
Project Armory - 2.16 Dev (Released 2014-11-16)
===========================================

- [ADDED] Add categories to all weapons
- [ADDED] New Weapon: [Project Armory] CS-18
- [ADDED] New weapon: [Star Wars] DH17 Blaster
- [ADDED] New Weapon: [Star Wars] DL44 Blaster
- [ADDED] New Weapon: [Star Wars] EE-3 Carbine Rifle
- [CHANGED] Bolter and Bolt Pistol secondary explosions added. Stat tweaks. (Need to be tested)
- [CHANGED] Lowered damage on M-81 Pulse Rifle
- [CHANGED] Range is to long SA.58 Tactical
- [CHANGED] Range is to short FAMAS-G2
- [FIXED] Mauser C96 is named M2 Browning
- [FIXED] Vanilla weapons was deactivated and the Pistol missed its texture

Download it here:
http://dev.evul.nu/rimworld/ProjectArmory/devbuilds/index.php

JuliaEllie

#64
November 16, 2014, 04:16:31 PM
Is this meant to be public??

Evul

#65
November 16, 2014, 04:18:05 PM
Yes we do public devbuilds from now on end.

They one; might not work, two; lack stuff textures features and might even crash.

Kantalope

#66
November 19, 2014, 06:01:01 PM
I can test it

Evul

#67
November 19, 2014, 09:58:39 PM
The download link is here:

Quote from: Evul on November 16, 2014, 03:51:37 PM
New DevBuild is released.
New devbuild is released download it throe the link provided. This is not a official release and may features might be lacking. This version can also be weary unstable.

Report bugs or things that need to be balanced i this thread!

Changelog:
Code Select
===========================================
Project Armory - 2.16 Dev (Released 2014-11-16)
===========================================

- [ADDED] Add categories to all weapons
- [ADDED] New Weapon: [Project Armory] CS-18
- [ADDED] New weapon: [Star Wars] DH17 Blaster
- [ADDED] New Weapon: [Star Wars] DL44 Blaster
- [ADDED] New Weapon: [Star Wars] EE-3 Carbine Rifle
- [CHANGED] Bolter and Bolt Pistol secondary explosions added. Stat tweaks. (Need to be tested)
- [CHANGED] Lowered damage on M-81 Pulse Rifle
- [CHANGED] Range is to long SA.58 Tactical
- [CHANGED] Range is to short FAMAS-G2
- [FIXED] Mauser C96 is named M2 Browning
- [FIXED] Vanilla weapons was deactivated and the Pistol missed its texture

Download it here:
http://dev.evul.nu/rimworld/ProjectArmory/devbuilds/index.php


Print
Go Up Pages 1 ... 3 4 5
User actions